Are you tired of losing your food to the grill monsters? You need to find the best grill mat so those days of frustration are over!
The days of yanking at that perfectly infused piece of gorgeous chicken that sits ruined and immovable on your grill? (Sad day!)
What about the spears of asparagus that fall into the grill abyss?
Well, NEVER AGAIN!
If you are an outdoor culinary mogul that grills outside every weekend like many others, protecting your grill with the best grill mat is vital.
A grill mat defends against small and large pieces of food from dropping through the grates, protects your grill from damage, and prevents messiness from waste dropping into the abyss.
Plus, it's a great item to have if you're headed to the park to grill on a public grill. It will protect your food from dirty grates.
Table of Contents
Our Choices for The Best Grill Mat
Best Grill Mat Reviews
Below you will find the top 5 best BBQ grill mats that you can rely on.
Amazon’s #1 Best Selling Grill Mat (Grill Griddles)
These mats would be perfect for the everyday grill master to the weekend trooper alike.
Comes in a set of two non-stick BBQ grill mats, which are heavy duty, reusable, and easy to clean.
The mats measure 15.8 x 13 x 0.1 inches, are made from heavy duty PTFE (PFOA Free), can be placed on top of any grilling area (charcoal, gas, or electric) with temperatures up to 500 degrees F, are 100% non-stick, and are dishwasher safe.
You can even see the grill marks, which make grilling a fantasy. These mats are perfect for chicken wings, BBQ ribs, burgers, steaks, fish, vegetables, and even pizza.
No more messes to clean up and you will never BBQ on a nasty, dirty grill grate again!
The only grill mat recommended by Chris Kimball of America’s Test Kitchen and it comes with a Lifetime Replacement Guarantee!
Amazon’s #1 Best Selling Grill Mat (Barbecue Grids)
These nonstick BBQ grill mats make grilling easy - perfect for charcoal, electric, and gas grill - reusable, easy to clean - and an essential grilling accessory for home cooks and pro grillers.
Each pack contains a set of three 15.75" x 13" x 0.02" cooking mats. That means no more scrubbing grill grates every time you cook!
Just lay the grill mats directly on any outdoor grilling space then take your grilling to the next level.
The Twisted Chef grill mats work wonderfully with great heat distribution, cook food perfectly, and leaves nice grill marks on burgers.
After you are finished eating, simply remove the mat once it has cooled down, wipe off with a damp cloth, and throw it on the top shelf of the dishwasher.
Now you can get back to your mates and crack open another craft beer, knowing these mats come with a "no hassle" LIFETIME guarantee. Cheers!
Amazon’s #1 Best Selling Grill Mat (Grill Toppers)
This is the thickest mat reviewed at 0.39mm!
This is a PFOA free, heavy-duty 600-degree non-stick mat that comes in a set of two. Top amateur grill masters and professional chefs use these beasts worldwide.
Harder to clean than other mats (it may take some elbow grease to get some of the particles off), but not too bad.
These are solid grill mats with a seven year warranty that would make a great addition to your BBQ accessory family.
Amazon’s #1 Best Selling Grill Mat (Oven Parts & Accessories)
These eco-friendly, large, non-stick oven liners come in a 3 pack and are certified BPA and PFOA free and made of a FDA approved Teflon material.
Each mat is 23” x 16.25”, safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, are non-stick, reusable, and dishwasher safe.
They can be cut to fit your grill perfectly and wipe clean fairly easily.
FitFabHome also offers a 100% Guarantee.
This is an awesome product, works great, and we like that they are guaranteed BPA free.
If you want to say no to those thin grill mats, the thick PhatMat Griller mesh mat might just be the answer!
While a differently designed grill mat than others reviewed above, its worth a consideration.
The nonstick mesh means food taste better and keeps your food from falling between the grates, yet allows for evenly grilled food every time!
It comes in a set of two 16" x 11" mesh sheets made from heavy duty PTFE (PFOA Free) fabric coated with a food grade silicone, and is regarded as one of the best accessories for Traeger, RECTEC, and Big Green Egg.
Is mesh better than a mat? The mesh would be better if smoking for sure, as the mesh would expose the smoky flavors of the wood to the food better.
This mat is 100% non-stick and dishwasher safe. No more ruined food and it cleans up in a jiffy!
The Phatmat Griller mesh mat will change the way you think about grill mats and it comes with a lifetime guarantee so no worries if you’re not satisfied.
What exactly is a grill mat?
It is simply a solid layer of a plastic-like material with an added coating of a thick material referred to as PTFE (Poly-Tetra-Fluoro-Ethylene).
This unique coating can withstand high temperatures and, as such, foods can be cooked on it without it catching fire.
These mats are healthy, easy to use, and prevent foods from falling through or sticking to the grill grates, which would otherwise be challenging to clean.
Additionally, the use of a mat when grilling helps with reducing the amount of oil used, since not much of it spills away.
Though many mats claim to offer these and other benefits, not all of them are worth of your dollars.
Never place a grill mat directly on hot charcoals or directly on a flame. Ideally, lay the mat over grill grates about 7" from flames/burners.
What to Expect from the Best Grilling Mats
Basically, every grill mat on the market today has certain features in common with all others. All are constructed of the same materials – fiberglass cloth and some version of Poly-Tetra-Fluoro-Ethylene (PTFE).
Even though they all look basically the same – a flexible black rectangle with a nonstick coating – there are some big differences you will want to be aware of when shopping for one, so that you purchase a grill mat that’s perfect for your needs.
The factors to consider are 3 fold: the amount of PTFE, the size of the mat, and the thickness of the mat.
Amount of PTFE
The PTFE sheet needs to be thick enough to withstand the heat and cook food evenly. Having the wrong mat will possibly create uneven cooking surface, which means it will produce unpredictable cooking results.
If the grill mat is too thin, it will gather heat too rapidly and will very likely burn through the mat, which is never good.
BBQ Grill Mat Size - Is Bigger Better?
Grill mats generally come in a similar width, give or take a few centimeters.
The length can vary a bit, anywhere from 13 inches up to 17 inches.
Consequently, if you can find a perfect fit to your grill, the thickness you desire, and also has the extra coatings of PTFE, that’s definitely the way to go. That’s as good as it gets!
Some of the top outdoor grill masters prefer the larger-sized mats, partly for the added handiness of the extra workspace, but also because grill mat sheets can be cut with scissors to any size you need.
BBQ Grill Mat Thickness
This is probably the biggest difference in appearances and quality that you’ll see when comparing grill mats.
The thickness is directly related to the amount and type of nonstick layers. With some grill mats literally being paper thin and others being 0.39mm thick.
Super thin is never a good idea.
These 3 factors might not seem to add up to much of a difference, but these matter considerably in durability, ease of use, cleaning difficulty, longevity, how well it heats and cools on the grill, and how slick it is.
Best Grill Mat
So, now you know another secret to grilling like the PRO’s.
Even though most grill mats all look basically the same – a flexible black box with a nonstick layer – remember the following differences when spending your hard earned cash on one.
- the correct amount of PTFE for your needs;
- the appropriate size for your grill;
- the suitable thickness; and
- a good warranty.
Now you don’t have to worry yourself about cleaning out your grill ever again.
Choose any of these top BBQ mats and take your grilling proficiency to the next level.
Purchase one of these grill mats for yourself or gift one to a family member and, as always, enjoy your grilling festivities and grill/smoke like a pro at your next bbq!
What's been your experience with grill mats? Do you have a favorite? Let us know in the comments below!